Skip to main content
Four tools analyze how papers cite each other. Use them when the connections between papers matter more than keywords. Requires a Scite premium subscription. Counts reflect Scite’s index coverage, so say so when you report them.

citation_graph

citation_graph traverses citations from up to 10 seed DOIs. Each edge is {s, t, d}: the citing paper s, the cited paper t, and d, the hop distance from a seed.
The response carries edges, a papers map of every DOI to its title, year, and any editorialNotices, and truncated when max_edges was hit. Edge type is supporting, contradicting, or mentioning. contradicting here is the stance search_literature reports as contrasting. Snippet text returns only for open-access and unrestricted sources; closed-publisher edges still carry type and section. Seeds expand automatically to their linked preprint and published versions, so a paper split across an arXiv DOI and a journal DOI traverses as one work.

Check coverage first

seed_coverage maps each seed to how many of its edges resolved at hop 1, and low_coverage_seeds lists seeds with too few to be reliable. arXiv-heavy fields, such as machine learning, often under-resolve. A thin graph means missing edges, not a poorly connected paper; fall back to search_literature for low-coverage seeds.

Analyses you can derive from edges

The edge list answers the classic citation-analysis questions without extra calls:
  • Common references: traverse out from several seeds and keep DOIs that appear as t for every seed.
  • Common citers: traverse in and keep DOIs that appear as s for every seed. These are often surveys.
  • Bibliographic coupling: traverse both at depth 2, so the second hop reaches other papers that cite the seed’s references. Rank those papers by how many reference targets they share with the seed.
  • Co-citation: rank papers frequently cited by the same citers.
  • Citation classics: rank DOIs by in-degree.
Add include_intent first to filter any of these to supporting or contradicting edges.

The claim graph

Pass claim instead of seeds and the tool runs check_claim for you. The response adds claim_check, with the verbatim supporting, contradicting, and stating passages, and builds the graph from the papers that state the claim, always with intent on the edges. From there, call read_fulltext on claim_check.readNext (the stating papers) and claim_check.readNextCiting (the papers holding the counterexamples and evidence) to read the experiments, assumptions, and proofs behind each node.

get_citation_statements

get_citation_statements lists the Smart Citation statements that cite one paper, with paging. Unlike citation_graph, it pages cleanly through papers with tens of thousands of citers.
The response carries total and hasMore. Stance uses Scite’s expert label when one exists, else the classifier’s; confidence is the classifier’s 0–1 score. snippet is verbatim for open-access and licensed sources; otherwise contentDenied is true and only type, section, and confidence return. For very heavily cited papers approximate is true: total counts a bounded slice, offset is capped (capped: true when yours was past it), and hasMore turns false at the last reachable page. Narrow with type or term rather than paging further.

bibliometrics

bibliometrics computes field-level citation analytics in one aggregation pass. It counts citations received by the papers in scope and returns no paper text.

Scope

Pass at least one filter: dois (up to 2,000), term, title, abstract, journal (word match) or journals (exact keys), author, affiliation, publisher, topic, paper_type, year, date_from, date_to, citation_types, sections, has_tally, and the editorial filters has_retraction, has_concern, has_correction, has_erratum, and has_withdrawn. term matches title, abstract, and full text, and every word must match. Check total_papers and tighten with quotes, AND/OR, dates, topic, or journals.

Grouping

group_by sets the bucket dimension: year (default), journal, author, affiliation, topic, mesh, paper_type, oa_status, editorial_notice, citation_type, or citation_section. order_by ranks buckets by papers, citations, supporting, contrasting, or mentioning; year buckets are always chronological. limit caps buckets at up to 100.

What it returns

contrast_rate is contrasting ÷ (supporting + contrasting). Most fields sit around 0.05–0.08; a bucket well above that is worth reading.

Normalized and custom indices

Pass baseline, an object with the same filters describing the field, to get normalized: mncs (1.0 = field average), tncs, and Leiden pp_top1, pp_top10, and pp_top50. Pass custom_indices to compute your own h, g, or at-least indices over any tally field. For example, {"type": "h", "field": "contrasting", "name": "negative_h"} returns the number of papers each disputed by at least that many contradicting citations. Set include_raw: true (with raw_limit up to 1,000) to get per-paper rows for computing other indices yourself.
Indicators support judgment; they don’t replace it. Normalize across fields with baseline, and don’t rank individual researchers on h-index or journal impact factor alone. See the Leiden Manifesto and DORA.

citation_dynamics

citation_dynamics analyzes when and how a set of papers was cited. Pass up to 100 DOIs, or up to 500 with summary_only: true. The DOIs usually come from bibliometrics (top_papers or include_raw), search_literature, or citation_graph.
Per paper, it returns citation timing (first_citation_year, peak_year, cited_half_life, within_1y/within_3y/within_5y, delayed_recognition), self_citation_rate, stance counts, editorial notices with citations_after_notice and stance_after_notice, and reference-list measures (mean_reference_age, price_index, journal_insularity). The aggregate adds citations_by_citing_year, cohorts (cited year × citing year), stance_by_citing_year, references_by_year, and top_cited_references. Common uses:
  • Journal citation-rate estimates. Pass one journal’s papers from years Y-1 and Y-2 (from bibliometrics with journals, year, and include_raw). Then (cohorts[Y-1][Y] + cohorts[Y-2][Y]) ÷ papers approximates a two-year impact factor, and cohorts[Y][Y] ÷ papers approximates immediacy for year-Y papers. These are estimates from Scite’s index, not official Journal Impact Factors: the denominator counts every paper supplied rather than citable items only. Above 500 papers, summary_only covers only the 500 most-cited, so the value overstates the rate.
  • Post-retraction citation. stance_after_notice still showing supporting citations means papers kept citing the work as valid.
  • Shifting stance. A rising contradicting share in stance_by_citing_year is a signal to read the contradicting passages, not a verdict that the finding is weakening.
  • Fair comparisons. Use within_3y instead of all-time counts, and quote self_citation_rate beside any individual index.